{"items":[{"id":"r9-pp-01-1","english":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 40% to 50%.","ainglish":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 50%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":1,"base":40,"delta":10,"final":50}},{"id":"r9-pp-01-2","english":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 40% to 44%.","ainglish":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 44%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":1,"base":40,"delta":10,"final":44}},{"id":"r9-pp-01-3","english":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 40% to 53%.","ainglish":"The cache-hit rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 53%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":1,"base":40,"delta":10,"final":53}},{"id":"r9-pp-02-1","english":"The successful-login rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 50% to 70%.","ainglish":"The successful-login rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 70%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":2,"base":50,"delta":20,"final":70}},{"id":"r9-pp-02-2","english":"The successful-login rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","ainglish":"The successful-login rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":2,"base":50,"delta":20,"final":60}},{"id":"r9-pp-02-3","english":"The successful-login rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 50% to 73%.","ainglish":"The successful-login rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 73%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":2,"base":50,"delta":20,"final":73}},{"id":"r9-pp-03-1","english":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5% this cycle, from 60% to 65%.","ainglish":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 65%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":3,"base":60,"delta":5,"final":65}},{"id":"r9-pp-03-2","english":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5% this cycle, from 60% to 63%.","ainglish":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 63%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":3,"base":60,"delta":5,"final":63}},{"id":"r9-pp-03-3","english":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5% this cycle, from 60% to 68%.","ainglish":"The on-time delivery rate rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 68%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":3,"base":60,"delta":5,"final":68}},{"id":"r9-pp-04-1","english":"The test-pass rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 25% to 45%.","ainglish":"The test-pass rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 45%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":4,"base":25,"delta":20,"final":45}},{"id":"r9-pp-04-2","english":"The test-pass rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 25% to 30%.","ainglish":"The test-pass rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 30%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":4,"base":25,"delta":20,"final":30}},{"id":"r9-pp-04-3","english":"The test-pass rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 25% to 48%.","ainglish":"The test-pass rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 48%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":4,"base":25,"delta":20,"final":48}},{"id":"r9-pp-05-1","english":"The renewal rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 80% to 90%.","ainglish":"The renewal rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 90%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":5,"base":80,"delta":10,"final":90}},{"id":"r9-pp-05-2","english":"The renewal rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 80% to 88%.","ainglish":"The renewal rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 88%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":5,"base":80,"delta":10,"final":88}},{"id":"r9-pp-05-3","english":"The renewal rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 80% to 93%.","ainglish":"The renewal rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 93%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":5,"base":80,"delta":10,"final":93}},{"id":"r9-pp-06-1","english":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 30% to 40%.","ainglish":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 30% to 40%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":6,"base":30,"delta":10,"final":40}},{"id":"r9-pp-06-2","english":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 30% to 33%.","ainglish":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 30% to 33%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":6,"base":30,"delta":10,"final":33}},{"id":"r9-pp-06-3","english":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 30% to 43%.","ainglish":"The alert resolution rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 30% to 43%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":6,"base":30,"delta":10,"final":43}},{"id":"r9-pp-07-1","english":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","ainglish":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":7,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":60}},{"id":"r9-pp-07-2","english":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 55%.","ainglish":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 55%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":7,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":55}},{"id":"r9-pp-07-3","english":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 63%.","ainglish":"The vaccination coverage rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 63%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":7,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":63}},{"id":"r9-pp-08-1","english":"The survey response rate rose by 25% this cycle, from 40% to 65%.","ainglish":"The survey response rate rose by 25 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 65%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":8,"base":40,"delta":25,"final":65}},{"id":"r9-pp-08-2","english":"The survey response rate rose by 25% this cycle, from 40% to 50%.","ainglish":"The survey response rate rose by 25 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 50%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":8,"base":40,"delta":25,"final":50}},{"id":"r9-pp-08-3","english":"The survey response rate rose by 25% this cycle, from 40% to 68%.","ainglish":"The survey response rate rose by 25 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 68%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":8,"base":40,"delta":25,"final":68}},{"id":"r9-pp-09-1","english":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 20% to 40%.","ainglish":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 20% to 40%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":9,"base":20,"delta":20,"final":40}},{"id":"r9-pp-09-2","english":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 20% to 24%.","ainglish":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 20% to 24%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":9,"base":20,"delta":20,"final":24}},{"id":"r9-pp-09-3","english":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20% this cycle, from 20% to 43%.","ainglish":"The first-attempt completion rate rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 20% to 43%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":9,"base":20,"delta":20,"final":43}},{"id":"r9-pp-10-1","english":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20% this cycle, from 75% to 95%.","ainglish":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 75% to 95%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":10,"base":75,"delta":20,"final":95}},{"id":"r9-pp-10-2","english":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20% this cycle, from 75% to 90%.","ainglish":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 75% to 90%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":10,"base":75,"delta":20,"final":90}},{"id":"r9-pp-10-3","english":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20% this cycle, from 75% to 98%.","ainglish":"The inventory accuracy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 75% to 98%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":10,"base":75,"delta":20,"final":98}},{"id":"r9-pp-11-1","english":"The opt-in rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 60% to 70%.","ainglish":"The opt-in rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 70%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":11,"base":60,"delta":10,"final":70}},{"id":"r9-pp-11-2","english":"The opt-in rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 60% to 66%.","ainglish":"The opt-in rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 66%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":11,"base":60,"delta":10,"final":66}},{"id":"r9-pp-11-3","english":"The opt-in rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 60% to 73%.","ainglish":"The opt-in rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 60% to 73%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":11,"base":60,"delta":10,"final":73}},{"id":"r9-pp-12-1","english":"The recovery success rate rose by 30% this cycle, from 50% to 80%.","ainglish":"The recovery success rate rose by 30 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 80%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":12,"base":50,"delta":30,"final":80}},{"id":"r9-pp-12-2","english":"The recovery success rate rose by 30% this cycle, from 50% to 65%.","ainglish":"The recovery success rate rose by 30 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 65%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":12,"base":50,"delta":30,"final":65}},{"id":"r9-pp-12-3","english":"The recovery success rate rose by 30% this cycle, from 50% to 83%.","ainglish":"The recovery success rate rose by 30 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 83%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":12,"base":50,"delta":30,"final":83}},{"id":"r9-pp-13-1","english":"The rail punctuality rose by 5% this cycle, from 80% to 85%.","ainglish":"The rail punctuality rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 85%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":13,"base":80,"delta":5,"final":85}},{"id":"r9-pp-13-2","english":"The rail punctuality rose by 5% this cycle, from 80% to 84%.","ainglish":"The rail punctuality rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 84%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":13,"base":80,"delta":5,"final":84}},{"id":"r9-pp-13-3","english":"The rail punctuality rose by 5% this cycle, from 80% to 88%.","ainglish":"The rail punctuality rose by 5 percentage points this cycle, from 80% to 88%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":13,"base":80,"delta":5,"final":88}},{"id":"r9-pp-14-1","english":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40% this cycle, from 25% to 65%.","ainglish":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 65%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":14,"base":25,"delta":40,"final":65}},{"id":"r9-pp-14-2","english":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40% this cycle, from 25% to 35%.","ainglish":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 35%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":14,"base":25,"delta":40,"final":35}},{"id":"r9-pp-14-3","english":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40% this cycle, from 25% to 68%.","ainglish":"The audit sampling rate rose by 40 percentage points this cycle, from 25% to 68%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":14,"base":25,"delta":40,"final":68}},{"id":"r9-pp-15-1","english":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20% this cycle, from 40% to 60%.","ainglish":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 60%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":15,"base":40,"delta":20,"final":60}},{"id":"r9-pp-15-2","english":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20% this cycle, from 40% to 48%.","ainglish":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 48%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":15,"base":40,"delta":20,"final":48}},{"id":"r9-pp-15-3","english":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20% this cycle, from 40% to 63%.","ainglish":"The habitat occupancy rose by 20 percentage points this cycle, from 40% to 63%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":15,"base":40,"delta":20,"final":63}},{"id":"r9-pp-16-1","english":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","ainglish":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 60%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["contradictory","cannot be determined","consistent"],"answer":"consistent","strata":{"condition":"additive-consistent","scenario":16,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":60}},{"id":"r9-pp-16-2","english":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 55%.","ainglish":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 55%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["cannot be determined","consistent","contradictory"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"relative-collision","scenario":16,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":55}},{"id":"r9-pp-16-3","english":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10% this cycle, from 50% to 63%.","ainglish":"The payment settlement rate rose by 10 percentage points this cycle, from 50% to 63%.","question":"Under the stated change unit, are the three numeric claims internally consistent?","options":["consistent","contradictory","cannot be determined"],"answer":"contradictory","strata":{"condition":"both-inconsistent","scenario":16,"base":50,"delta":10,"final":63}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-01","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["cannot tell","rejected","approved"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-02","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-03","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-04","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["cannot tell","rejected","approved"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-05","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-06","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-07","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["cannot tell","rejected","approved"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-08","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-09","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-10","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["cannot tell","rejected","approved"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-11","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as approved.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"approved","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}},{"id":"r9-pp-cal-12","calibration":true,"english":"The status board records a decision, but does not state which decision.","ainglish":"The status board records the decision as rejected.","question":"Which decision does the board record?","options":["approved","rejected","cannot tell"],"answer":"rejected","strata":{"control":"construct-free-planted-effect"}}]}